Free 4-Week Paleo Meal Plan

Filled with delicious recipes and beautiful photos, this is a fantastic way to kick start your Paleo diet with ease!

Free Meal Plan

Paleo Ketchup Recipe

Written by Louise Hendon on March 9
homemade paleo gluten free ketchup recipe

Ketchup (or Catsup) is so common a condiment that we often forget it’s not Paleo! In fact, if you look at a bottle of Heinz Tomato Ketchup, you’ll find that it’s loaded with high fructose corn syrup, corn syrup, and “natural flavorings” (I always find this rather suspicious as it could mean a lot of different things).

The solution? Make your own Paleo ketchup! When I first decided to make Paleo ketchup, I thought it was going to be a ton of work, but it turned out to be remarkably simple. This Paleo ketchup recipe is my favorite one – there’s a great mix of spices to make it really flavorful.

Amazing TIP: In case you miss it in the recipe, I also added in little bit of gelatin (it makes it a tiny bit thicker but doesn’t really change the consistency even when refrigerated, but provides some added health benefits!).

Click Here To Download This Recipe As A Printable PDF


homemade paleo gluten free ketchup recipehomemade paleo gluten free ketchup recipe

After you’ve made this amazing Paleo ketchup recipe, enjoy it with some Paleo chicken nuggets (recipe here) or Paleo popcorn shrimp (recipe here).

Paleo Ketchup Recipe
Cook time
Total time
Serves: approx. ¾ cup
  1. Heat a saucepan on the stove on medium heat and add in the water and tomato paste. Stir well.
  2. Then add in the rest of the ingredients and stir until fully combined.
  3. Cool and store in airtight glass jars in the fridge (it should last 2-4 weeks).

Monica - June 27

Could you use Knox gelatin powder or perhaps chia seeds?

    Louise Hendon - June 28

    Yep – they should be fine as long as they don’t contain anything other than gelatin. You actually don’t need to add this to the ketchup – I like to add it just to boost the nutritional benefit of ketchup. The recipe will work just fine without it :)

Doris - August 30

Why use gelatin at , what use is it

Comments are closed